JUPITER, Fla.—When women or men receive the diagnosis of breast cancer, that news comes with an important piece of information — whether their cancer is HER2-positive or HER2-negative. It can be especially difficult to hear that one’s cancer is HER2-negative, because it means an effective group of targeted anti-cancer drugs isn’t helpful in those circumstances.
A new study from the lab of Scripps Research chemist Matthew D. Disney, Ph.D., entitled “A Designed Precision Small Molecule Inhibiting a Noncoding RNA Sensitives HER2 Negative Cancer to Herceptin,” suggests that in the future HER2 status may not be the final word on the matter.
Writing in the Journal of the American Chemical Society, Disney’s group described shifting three different cancer cell lines from HER2-negative status to HER2-positive status with the addition of a selective micro-RNA binding molecule they referred to as TGP-515. It’s a revolutionary idea, that a cancer’s genotype might not have to be the limiting factor in its range of targeted treatment options.
The research team designed their compound by using a mathematical system Disney developed called Inforna. The compound rendered the cancer cells vulnerable to both Herceptin (trastuzumab) and Kadcyla (ado-trastuzumab emtansine) targeted therapeutics, and left healthy breast cells unaffected.
“It’s possible that precision medicines like Herceptin can be made available to a wider group of people by altering gene expression with therapeutics that bind not to the proteins but to noncoding RNA,” Disney explained.
About 20 percent of people diagnosed with breast cancer have the HER2-positive mutation, which means the surface of their cancer cells have more of the HER2 protein on them. While that mutation is associated with faster growing and more aggressive cancers, since 1998 it has come with good options for effective treatment. Since the monoclonal antibody drug Herceptin was introduced, 10-year disease-free survival rates for the HER2-positive breast cancer subtype surged to 84 percent. For breast cancer patients with dwindling options, switching on HER2 sensitivity might be life-changing, according to Disney.
“This study is proof of concept for the strategy of creating sensitivity to a drug where one otherwise wouldn’t exist. It also validates the notion that transcription of genes can be modulated via small molecule compounds engineered to bind to relevant noncoding RNA. This means that supposedly untreatable diseases may, one day, be readily treatable. There is a long way to go for this to get to patients, however,” said Disney.
There were many challenges that had to be overcome to create the effective compound, added first author Matthew G. Costales, a Scripps Research graduate student. Unintended targets had to be identified and blocked, and selectivity engineered into the molecule. Disney’s computational system, Inforna, guided the efforts.
The first compound the Inforna database highlighted bound to two different micro RNAs, both 885 and 515. Further refinement made it clear that a compound could be designed to be selective for one micro RNA, but not the other. Researchers created a molecule that successfully selected only for the desired microRNA, 515, the result of which was that cancer cells produced increased HER2 levels, making them sensitive to the anti-cancer drugs.
“The demanding synthetic, biochemical, and cellular experiments described in this paper were three years in the making,” Costales points out. “It required tremendous effort, but the work is by no means complete. I am looking forward to future work guided by the lessons we learned here.”
Disney also credits his colleague, Scripps Research chemist Alexander Adibekian, Ph.D., with helping understand the mechanisms of action of their compound, TGP-515, and demonstrating its selectivity.
Disney noted that this is just the first step in a long series of work ahead to enable the technology to benefit cancer patients, and to boost HER2 sensitivity where there is none. Significant additional research lies ahead, he says, and successful tests in cultured cells must be followed with tests in mouse models of cancer, a process that will take several years.
“These studies would not have been realized without the local support graciously provided by the community,” Disney concludes. “I am incredibly grateful for the community taking the time to invest in the future of biomedical research completed here at Scripps Research.”
This research was made possible by the R.J. Scheller Graduate Student Fellowship, the ACS Medicinal Chemistry Division Predoctoral Fellowship, the National Institutes of Health, Alan and Susan Fuirst, and Frenchman’s Creek Women for Cancer Research.